Logan Coach horse trailers

Popup Hitch, gooseneck extensions SuperSprings, overloads Centramatic, tire balancers

mrtruck pickup truck reviews

As seen on

"Trailer Towing Education Starts Here"


Since 1999, made in USA

The Truth about Trucks

MrTruck Index

Home Page
Horse Trailer Reviews
Pickup Truck Reviews
Accessory Reviews
Towing Reviews
MrTruck.TV RFDTV Reviews

MrTruck Accessory Store Truck & Trailer Parts

Camper & RV
MrTruck Motors-Classified
Dept of Transport.
Hay Page
Truck News
Insurance Warranties
More Power
Oil & Filters
Recalls, Rebates, MPG
Tires Batteries
SUV Vans that tow
Trailer Basics & More
Truck Basics & More
Truck Safety

MrTruck Store Super Sale


Seven ft. 15 lb. Panels

Travel n corrals mounted on horse trailer

Peace of mind when horse camping


Auto Flex air ride suspensionComplete pickup truck leaf spring replacement with air bag suspension. Self levels, improves ride, braking, steering and handling. AutoFlex Review


Automated Safety Hitch Help for your Rear Truck Axle, an inline dually

Safety Hitch inline dually

Dramatic Trailer Braking & Turning for Safer Towing



Horse Trailer Super Store, shop open until midnight. Selling Cimarron, Logan Coach and Outlaw Conversions

EZ connector trailer wire connectionThis is the reliable weatherproof electrical connection for your trailer.

Logan Coach horse trailers

Strength of Steel Beauty of Aluminum

Whiz Proof Trailer Floors


BIGFOOT Hydraulic Trailer Jacks

Built to Outlast your Trailer, Steel Tank, covered leg

Big Foot steel enclosed foot trailer jack


Actuling electric over hydrauliic trailer brake actuator

DirecLink Trailer Brake Controller using your trucks computer with ABS brakes for your trailer from Tuson, best trailer brakes you can buy

Cimarron horse trailers

Cimarron Custom Aluminum Horse Trailers


Centramatic wheel automatic wheel balancers

Automatic Tire Balancers for Trucks and Trailers

25% to 50% longer tire life, eliminates cupping and tire vibration

Gander lock gooseneck lockGanderLock for Goosenecks: Protect your trailer as well as your expensive saddles, bridles, tools and flat screen TV. Goosenecks if you just lock the coupler, the thief's loosen the set bolts, slide out your adjustable coupler Read the Review
Express corralsExpress Corral Larger corral that goes up in 15 minutes, down in 10. For your trailer and pasture. Comes in a kit with an aluminum storage box. More.

Cattle and Horse Trailers, ask your neighbor

Titan stock trailer

New Polylast Floor video




Saddlematic power saddle rackMotorized Saddle Rack, save your back and shoulders and energy for your horse ride.


Step Above trailer ladderThe Safe heavy-duty trailer ladder you'll use. Read the story...

The Flip-Over Ball gooseneck hitch converts to smooth truck bed in seconds.



Maximum Trailer Braking Power for Serious Towing Trailer Brakes as fast as your Truck Brakes


Newly redesigned PopUp 2 Gooseneck Hitch. More info....


Weight Distributing

Weight Distributing Hitches for safe controlled trailer towing. Reviewing Equal-i-zer WDH Click.


Sulastic Rubber Springs are a cast hinge embedded with rubber. They greatly improve your trucks ride.

 Follow mrtruck on Twitter


2007 PickupTruck.com Heavy Duty Shootout, Part 1 of 3
By: Mike Levine, Kent Sundling, Mrtruck.com and Neil McGarry
© 2007 PickupTruck.com

Part 1: [1] [2] [3] [4]
[Intro] [Truck Specs] [Dodge] [General Motors] [Ford] [Squat Test]

Part 2: Quarter-Mile Drags
[Intro] [3/4-Ton Unloaded] [3/4-Ton Loaded] [1-Ton Unloaded] [1-Ton Loaded] [F-450] [Diesel v Gas Comparison]

Part 3: Hill Climbs
[Intro] [3/4-Ton 7% Grade] [1-Ton 7% Grade] [Diesel v Gas Comparison 7% Grade]
[3/4-Ton 15% Grade] [1-Ton 15% Grade] [Diesel v Gas Comparison 15% Grade]

[F-450 All Grades] [Summary]

Please support our sponsors!

Introduction and Some History

It’s hard to believe that it’s been almost five years since PickupTruck.com was challenged by its readers to quantitatively prove our assertions about which Class 3 heavy duty diesel pickup was the most capable of that time.

In late 2002 the diesel market was changing rapidly from intense competition between Chrysler, Ford, and General Motors. All had new or significantly revised diesel engines.


GM and Isuzu Motors had teamed up to produce the 6.6-liter Duramax V8. The Duramax, and its Allison-sourced gearbox, was a completely fresh design for GM. It was such an improvement over the old 6.5-liter engine it replaced that GM’s diesel market share increased from 3% to 25% in a single year after its release in 2000. Output was rated at 520 ft-lbs of torque at 1,800-rpm and 300-hp at 3,100-rpm. The race for the best, most powerful next-gen diesel was on.

In February 2002, Dodge and its powertrain partner Cummins came forward with a reengineered 5.9-liter I6. It introduced a high-pressure, common rail fuel-injection system and was capable of producing 555 ft-lbs at 1,400-rpm and 305-hp at 2,900-rpm.

Finally, in spring 2002, Ford threw down the gauntlet with Navistar to introduce the new 6.0-liter Power Stroke V8 diesel for the 2003 Super Duty. It replaced the earlier 7.3-liter PSD and pioneered new engine technology, like an electronic variable response turbo to dynamically manage airflow. The 6.0 PSD also claimed best in class torque and horsepower figures, at 560 ft-lbs at 2,000-rpm and 325-hp at 3,300-rpm.

So when Ford invited us in October 2002 to drive the new 6.0-liter PSD and our initial impressions said this was the best motor in its class, we were promptly skewered by our (Duramax and Cummins) readers because we didn’t have empirical data to back up our claims.

(The 6.0 PSD would later suffer from notorious reliability issues that continue to haunt and sour the Ford-Navistar relationship to this day.)

The ‘we’ in this story was Mike Levine, PUTC’s editor, and Tom Keefe, a top-notch marketing and communications consultant who had helped GM launch the GMT 800 pickups and the Duramax.

In the incredibly short time span of three weeks, Tom and Mike pulled together six different heavy duty diesels from Dodge, Ford, and GM for a head-to-head challenge to determine which pickup was most capable.

While Mike looked for a sponsor, Tom managed all of the logistics. He setup the tests, ran the trucks in Michigan, and managed the third party vendor, Ricardo Inc., we hired to independently collect data about each truck.

Without Tom’s help, passion, and knowledge, the 2003 Western Diesel PickupTruck.com Heavy Duty Diesel Shootout would never have happened. But it did and it became the most popular story we’ve ever had on the site.

Tom passed away in 2003. For all of us who knew Tom, we’ll always remember him as one of the most knowledgeable and kind-hearted truck guys around. This year’s comparison is in his memory.

 Cover up your trailer hitch with trailer hitch plugs

The 2007 Shootout

It’s ironic that this year’s test also came together in a very short time span – about five weeks. But there are some notable differences from 2002.

The full-size pickup segment continues to change rapidly. Nissan and Toyota didn’t have competitive full-size, half-ton haulers back in 2002. Now they do, so the heavy duty three quarter and one-ton segments represent the very last bastion of complete market domination by the Detroit Three in personal-use vehicles.

Like 2002, there are three all new or updated diesel engines we’re comparing but it’s not necessarily the competition that’s driving change so much as it’s new federal regulations implemented to strictly control diesel soot and nitrogen oxide (NOX) emissions. More about this later.

We’re no longer limiting the comparison to just lean burning diesels. This year we’ve broken the HD trucks into two groups. The first group is single rear wheel (SRW) three-quarter-ton crew cab short-bed 4x4s with gas engines. The second group is dual rear wheel (DRW) one-ton crew cab long-bed 4x4s with compression ignition motors. They are all automatics, since the trend among buyers is moving away from manual transmissions. GM no longer offers an HD pickup with a manual shifter.

There’s one more diesel – but it’s in a class all its own. We’ve included Ford’s all new 2007 F-450 Class 4 pickup. It’s the first one-and-one-half-ton chassis cab truck to come from the factory with a standard truck bed. We’re guessing it won’t be the last of its kind either.

And joining up with PickupTruck.com to help with this comparison is Kent Sundling – a.k.a. MrTruck.com. Kent knows everything there is to know about towing and hauling. After all, Kent has a ‘BS in Trucknology’. We’re very pleased to have Kent on board for this comparison. If you haven’t done so, you need to take some time to visit Kent’s many truck websites.

We’ve kept the test scenarios the same as the 2002 Shootout plus added a few new ones.

Each test was performed unloaded and towing a 10,500-pound trailer. This put us just a hair over current light duty towing thresholds for most half-ton pickups, except for the 11,000-lb capable Ford F-150.

Before the testing started, we topped off each vehicle with fuel and measured their curb weight, minus passengers, at a truck stop in Monroe, Michigan.

PickupTruck.com rented Milan Dragway, about 45 miles southwest of Detroit, to run our one-ton ¼-mile tests down their International Hot Rod Association (IHRA) sanctioned asphalt. We think we broke two track records (but not the track) for the heaviest and longest vehicles to ever travel its 1,320-foot length, with the F-450 towing a 20,000-pound fifth wheel. Hey – we don’t mess around with our testing.

Part 1: [1] [2] [3] [4]